Mailchimp vs AWeber 2024: How to choose the best email tool

Email marketing remains among the most powerful forms of digital marketing; its adaptability, cost-effectiveness and direct reach is hard to beat.

Its capacity to deliver high returns on investment, build loyalty and drive conversions has not only kept it relevant, but given rise to numerous email automation software and platforms.

Mailchimp and AWeber are two such tools, both regularly featuring among businesses’ top-rated.

About Mailchimp

Mailchimp is a comprehensive marketing platform primarily known for its email capabilities. It has, however, expanded to include various other features to support businesses.

Here are some of Mailchimp’s core email marketing features:

Email campaigns

Email design : Create, send and manage email campaigns using customisable templates or a drag-and-drop email builder
Automation : Schedule automated emails such as welcome series and abandoned cart reminders
A/B testing : * Test different versions of content marketing emails to optimise performance

Contact management

Lead capture : Create opt-in forms and segment lists to target specific audiences
Customer segmentation : Organise contacts based on behaviour, purchase history and other elements for tailored campaigns

Reporting and analytics

Performance tracking : Monitor open rates, click-through rates, bounces and unsubscribes
Insights : Gain insights into customer behaviour to improve future content marketing campaigns

Additional features

Social media integration : Schedule and publish engaging content on social media platforms
Ecommerce integration : Sync with platforms like Shopify and WooCommerce to create targeted email campaigns based on store activity
Website and landing page builder : Build and publish websites and landing pages using a drag-and-drop editor
Geotargeting : Send targeted messages based on customers’ geographic locations

Advanced tools*

Multivariate testing : Test multiple variables in email campaigns
Customer journey builder : Create automated sales funnels with customisable conditions
Postcards : Send physical postcards for promotions and reminders

* These tools are available on paid and higher-tier plans

Who it can help

Mailchimp is most effective for small to mid-sized businesses. It is best suited for:

Marketing, education and social media services
Start-ups and small businesses
E-commerce and retail
Mobile and web apps
Online content marketing and copywriting agencies
Businesses needing integrations
Service providers

What it costs

Source: Mailchimp

About AWeber

AWeber is a cloud-based email marketing platform designed to help businesses manage their email marketing campaigns effectively and connect with subscribers.

Here are some of AWeber’s core email marketing features:

Email campaigns

Email design : Create and send digital marketing copy, newsletters, coupons and special offers using customisable templates or the Smart Designer AI-powered tool
Automation : Schedule automated messages, including welcome series and follow-up emails to build relationships and engage subscribers.
A/B testing : Test different versions of emails to optimise performance and improve engagement

Contact management

Lead capture : Create and publish opt-in forms on websites to capture subscriber information and build email lists
Customer segmentation : Organise contacts with detailed filters and tags based on behaviour, purchase history and custom fields for targeted campaigns

Reporting and analytics

Performance tracking : Monitor open rates, click-through rates, conversions, revenue over time and other metrics to evaluate campaign effectiveness
Insights : Gain insights into subscriber behaviour and campaign performance to refine future marketing efforts

Additional features

Landing page builder : Build and design landing pages using a variety of templates and smart content functionality to embed interactive content
Integrations : Gain access to a wide range of third-party tools and applications to enhance functionality
Subscriber management : Add, import and manage subscriber lists, including customising fields and excluding certain subscribers from specific campaigns

Advanced tools

Spam score calculation : Improve email deliverability by calculating and optimising spam scores
Custom workflows : Create automated workflows triggered by subscriber actions or tags to ensure relevant communication

Who it can help

AWeber is a solid choice for small businesses and start-ups. It is best suited for:

Small businesses and start-ups
Bloggers and content creators
Ecommerce businesses
Entrepreneurs and solopreneurs
Intermediate email marketers

What it costs

Source: AWeber
* Prices in US$

Mailchimp for email marketing: Pros and cons

Pros

Ease of use

Clean, user-friendly interface makes it easy to navigate and create campaigns

Email editor

Offers both ‘Classic’ and ‘New Builder’ editors with drag-and-drop functionality, integrated error-checking and copy optimisation tools

Marketing automation tools

The ‘Customer Journeys’ feature allows for creating automated sequences with pre-built templates

Segmentation

Advanced audience segmentation options based on demographics, behaviour and other criteria

Personalisation

Dynamic content insertion with merge tags allows for targeted and personalised email campaigns

Analytics and reporting

Real-time analytics, including detailed campaign performance metrics and custom reports

Email deliverability

Generally good deliverability rates, with domain verification and authentication options to improve inbox placement

Integrations

More than 300 integrations with popular tools like Shopify, Salesforce and Google Analytics

Cons

Affordability

Paid plans can become expensive quickly, especially for larger email lists. Charges include duplicates, unsubscribed and inactive contacts

Email template library

Limited selection of responsive and modern templates

Sign-up forms

Form builder is confusing, lacks a colour picker and options are not clearly presented

Landing pages

Limited design options, no start-from-scratch feature and lack of A/B testing

Split testing

Paid add-on for Litmus Inbox Preview, limited to email campaigns (no landing pages)

Customer support

Email support only available for 30 days for free users

Automation

Automation features are not as robust or intuitive compared to other tools

AWeber for email marketing: Pro and cons

Pros

Ease of use and setup

User-friendly; easy to import customers and create and segment lists
Stable platform, widely trusted by email marketers

Cost-effective for beginners

Free plan for businesses with fewer than 500 contacts

Customer support

Strong 24/7 customer service

Comprehensive email tools

More than 700 email templates
The ability to create custom designs using Canva
Users can automate email sequences, send RSS to email broadcasts and segment subscribers
Includes A/B testing for email campaigns

Analytics and reporting

Sophisticated email analytics and pre-designed reports to track key metrics

Integration and customisation

Integrates with numerous third-party apps and tools for seamless workflow
Supports both single-opt-in and double-opt-in for subscriber lists

Template and image library

Offers a vast library of customisable email templates and access to over 6,000 stock images

Cons

Pricing issues

Users are charged for subscribers even if they have unsubscribed
Multiple charges for single subscribers on multiple lists

Deliverability concerns

Some emails may land in spam folders
Lacks detailed deliverability safeguards and the ability to categorise delivery data based on email service providers

Outdated user interface

UI is considered by some to be outdated and cumbersome, hindering multitasking and smooth workflow
Steep learning curve

Limited A/B testing and reporting features

Landing page builder does not support A/B testing
Reports can sometimes be inaccurate or incomplete

Template and feature limitations

Some templates are outdated and may require significant customisation
The RSS to email feature has a limited selection of templates and can be difficult to convert and edit

Content is still king

While Mailchimp and AWeber are both good for email marketing, the ‘winner’ will be determined by personal preference based on their different offerings, strengths and weaknesses.

Whichever platform you choose though, it is important to remember that content reigns supreme; the success of your email marketing ultimately hinges on compelling, engaging content.

It may, thus, be wise to hire a professional content writing company to enhance your digital marketing copy and content strategy.

Contact Hunter & Scribe today and let compelling messaging and company newsletters be your secret weapon for email marketing success.

Refine Dev